Orphans of the state

Orphans of the state

A eunuch friend was followed by three thugs making lewd suggestions and stalking. With relief, she spotted a lady cop further down the road and hurried to her for help only to be dismissed with “tum dhanda karte hai is liye woh tumhare peeche aate hai” [they follow you because you are a prostitute].

I was furious, because even if she was a prostitute (which she wasn’t), she shouldn’t be sexually harassed or attacked. To me it was absolutely chilling that a WOMAN+Police Officer knowing that the men were likely looking for an opportunity to molest or rape her didn’t care at all. Instead she insulted her for asking for help by blaming her for her attackers intentions.

A policeman is our interface with the country’s law. That interface breaking down means people getting orphaned from the constitution, laws and rights.

This is a double problem, because it is difficult for victims of crimes to find justice and people also become victims of the police. Not to mention other problems like inefficiency, where police are simply not able to do what they are supposed to – even if they want.

In many ways, police are as orphaned by the state as we are. We are three years past the Mumbai Terror Attacks, and the police response is still dismal. Actually, you’d be lucky to get through to them first.

The fallout from this is massive. Difficulty getting cops to respond to a crisis. Difficulty getting cops to register cases they don’t see as important. Cops break the country’s laws in refusing justice at discretion. Difficulty getting any case registered against anyone affiliated with the ruling party. Human rights abuse and crimes by police. Bribe taking and giving. Anger and bloodshed over festering problems. Lack of trust in the rule of law. Lack of trust in government. Blot on the country’s human rights record. Weakening of democracy itself as citizens are selectively silenced or denied justice.

On the other hand, the police are orphaned themselves. They are overburdened, understaffed, underpaid, under equipped, under trained, unpopular. In other words, they are exhausted. Perpetually. They don’t want more cases coming in, and they work to prevent them from being reported, rather than committed – that takes least energy. They “compensate” themselves with bribes. They feel the power in channeling the country’s power at their own discretion. They are rarely appreciated, and often the criminals they arrest get released by some “pressure”. They are blamed for not responding well to things they have no clue how to respond to.

This 26th was the third anniversary of the death of Tukaram Omble who was key in capturing the only terrorist captured alive – Kasab. Omble was part of an ill-equipped team faced with stopping terrorists who had automatic rifles. The cops didn’t have a chance if the terrorists started spraying them with bullets. Omble shot one terrorist and tackled the other holding on to his gun and preventing him from using it so that the other policemen could capture him. In the process, Kasab let off bullets into Omble and he died. Armed with ancient rifles, and lacking bulletproof vests, a bunch of determined cops pulled this off. The same police force that took 45 minutes after the first alert to arrive at a location that was a five minute stroll from their headquarters.


What is basically missing here is the police being plugged into the country’s vision. They are abandoned, neglected and left to their own devices. They need to be integrated into the whole tightly.

The main steps for this will be:

  • Appreciation: Both monetary – in terms of more generous salaries, as well as emotional – attention to needs, prompt action to urgent ones, investment in their training so that they have greater skills and more pride.
  • Legislative maturity: When a Parliament keeps spewing out laws, I don’t know if they consider an understaffed and over-burdened police force having to enforce them. Failure adds to lawlessness. There needs to be a maturity in prioritizing. In the current state of lack of security, is it more important to police criminals, anti-social elements, monitor intelligence or police violators of a ridiculously exaggerated drinking age? Non-essential laws being scrapped will free police energies for the essentials. When a better state of security is established, the less important laws can be brought in if the government still thinks it important to micro-manage citizens.
  • Budget: As @primary_red points out, the budget for the police force is astonishingly low “India’s defense budget in 2011 was ~$36 Billion. The budget for police was ~$9 Billion.” Yet, the police force is larger, under a lot more day to day pressure, needs far more resources than it currently has. Of course, it doesn’t end up paying for accommodation of its employees away from their homes, but no one is asking to make them equal. But more is definitely needed for needs money can buy – equipment, training, facilities, salaries… More money needs allocated here if we expect better functioning.
  • Publicity: The role of police being publicized for its importance. The value of ethics, the high responsibility of the privilege to uphold a pillar of the democracy personally. Recruitment should be well advertised till needed strength of forces is achieved.
  • Training and equipment: I don’t know how to describe it. They need great weapons, bulletproof vests and training for both effectiveness as well as emotional skills and leadership. Training that instills a sense of pride in upholding the law with as much integrity as they are capable of… and raising the bar. Engaging them in the country’s goals as equal partners rather than the fetch and carry boys.
  • Accountability: Demanding that the laws of the country be upheld and available to absolutely any citizen regardless of religion, caste, class, ethnicity… or even nationality. Investigating deviations, researching them to improve.
  • Encouraging and safeguarding whistleblowing: The whistleblowers bill coming up will help, but it must be clear and well promoted that the state is interested in knowing what the cops are up to, and that it will lead to appropriate responses and actions and will actively protect the whistle blower from any fallout of their providing information.
  • Exemplary punishment: Deliberately breaking the country’s laws should be seen as an attack on democracy and treason – particularly for more serious crimes involving death or injury or crippling losses. There should be no attempts to prevent cops from being called to account. Any attempt to prevent investigations into police actions should be considered as complicity and the person interfering should be added as an accused.


Indian Police badge

So who will bell this cat? The government – it MUST. Or it must step aside to make way for another that will. But most importantly, if the government doesn’t, then because we are a democracy, it is our job to see it happen. Our job to do whatever it takes to remember and keep the pressure on and keep asking difficult questions till resolution. It shouldn’t be thus, but then our country is in such a phase. So we must.

The next few years are going to be important years of reinventing ourselves as a country. If we are able to bring our cops in on the story, their transformation will contribute to our transformation as a whole. If we ignore it, it will fail us when we need it most and delay or reverse much needed changes in the country.

It is important to not outrage for a day and forget, but to choose carefully the outrages you want to highlight and then follow them on to the end. Let no important news from the country be yesterday’s news till resolved.